|||

State of the World’s Volunteerism - neatly balanced, maybe?

Just got back from Istanbul (actually an industrial estate outside Istanbul) to take part in a regional meeting to contribute to the State of the World’s Volunteerism Report which is to come out next year for International Year of Volunteering.

The author, Robert Leigh, wants to expand the boundaries of the dominant paradigm” of volunteering: to shift attention away from formalised volunteering, mostly conducted under the auspices of formal organisations like NGOs, to include other kinds of work, often more bonding” than bridging” such as mutual self-help in rural areas, further away from the current influence and interest of international organisations.

This is pretty much the same conclusion we came to in the regional report for SEE and CIS States - see another post on this site. One big motivation for wanting to make this paradigm shift is that if you look at formalised volunteering it seems to be massively more prevalent in Western Europe and North America and hardly to exist at all in most other countries, which just doesn’t seem plausible; and certainly, if you look harder, you will find other examples of less formalised volunteering in these other countries.

Wouldn’t it be nice if formalised volunteering in which the Western countries excel was neatly balanced out by these other forms of volunteerism in the rest of the world? Of course it would.

But do we know that these other forms of volunteering a) are really significant in magnitude b) make a really significant contribution to wellbeing and c) can be usefully labelled volunteering” without overstretching our ordinary understanding of the word?

I fear we don’t.

Will there be time to gather evidence in support of this new paradigm in time for the report publication? Yes. Will there be time to make an overwhelmingly convincing case for it (or to reject or modify it as appropriate)? Let’s see.

Up next Value and measurability in development There is an interesting discussion on the xceval mailing list right now about value and measurability in development. Seems to me there are four Volunteering, the flip side of work? Just been to a meeting in Istanbul on the “state of the worlds volunteerism”, where there was a lot of talk about the definition of volunteerism and
Latest posts Causal Mapping - an earlier guide The walk to school in Sarajevo Glitches Draft blog post for AEA365 Theory Maker! Inventory & analysis of small conservation grants, C&W Africa - Powell & Mesbach! Lots of charts! Answering the “why” question: piecing together multiple pieces of causal information rbind.fill for 1-dimensional tables in r yED graph editor Examples of trivial graph format Using attr labels for ggplot An evaluation puzzle: “Talent show” An evaluation puzzle: “Mobile first” An evaluation puzzle: “Many hands” An evaluation puzzle: Loaves and fishes An evaluation puzzle: “Freak weather” An evaluation puzzle: “Billionaire” Publications Using Dropbox for syncing Shiny app data on Amazon EC2 Progress on the Causal Map app Articles and presentations related to Causal Maps and Theorymaker Better ways to present country-level data on a world map: equal-area cartograms A starter kit for reproducible research with R A reproducible workflow for evaluation reports Welcome to the Wiggle Room Realtime comments on a Theory of Change Responses to open questions shown as tooltips in a chart A panel on visualising Theories of Change for EES 2018? Peer mentoring for evaluators How do you explain reproducible research to clients? Links for my AEA eval2017 presentation, Washington DC