March 18, 2018

An evaluation puzzle: Loaves and fishes

Oxfam fixes the road after the flood, and Save the Children fixes the school.

The school couldn’t have been fixed without the road.

Both of the charities report to the UNs standardised reporting format, and both record their contribution as one school fixed”. Both argue: if our organisation hadn’t stepped in, the school wouldn’t have been built (counterfactual) but we did step in, and it was. Ergo, our organisation caused the fixing of the school.

So when the UN aggregates the reports, will it find that a total of two schools were repaired?

You are asked to comment on the reports.


puzzles


Previous post
An evaluation puzzle: “Billionaire” A billionaire left 10 million EUR in his will to establish a trust, with instructions that it should be used to “just do good”. During the ten years
Next post
An evaluation puzzle: “Many hands” In its report, CARE say they saved the villagers from being swept away in the flood. A critic argues, even if CARE hadn’t intervened


This blog by Steve Powell is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, syndicated on r-bloggers and powered by Blot.
Privacy Policy
.